diff --git a/media-creator/scripts/upload-media.sh b/media-creator/scripts/upload-media.sh
index 50750d0f..5bba55b1 100755
--- a/media-creator/scripts/upload-media.sh
+++ b/media-creator/scripts/upload-media.sh
@@ -101,10 +101,7 @@ upload "$WEB_IMAGES/search-alert-poster-dark.jpg" "images/search-alert-poster-da
 # Two widths per theme: the desktop shot is illegible scaled into a phone column, so the page picks
 # with a <picture> media query.
 for theme in light dark; do
-  for suffix in "" "-narrow"; do
-    upload "$WEB_IMAGES/vote-tally-${theme}${suffix}.webp" \
-      "images/vote-tally-${theme}${suffix}.webp" "image/webp"
-  done
+    upload "$WEB_IMAGES/vote-tally-${theme}.png" "images/vote-tally-${theme}.png" "image/png"
 done
 
 echo
diff --git a/web/components/about/vote-evidence.tsx b/web/components/about/vote-evidence.tsx
index 85dc91a8..357ca5ce 100644
--- a/web/components/about/vote-evidence.tsx
+++ b/web/components/about/vote-evidence.tsx
@@ -63,7 +63,7 @@ function Shot({theme, alt, className}: {theme: 'light' | 'dark'; alt: string; cl
           matching source wins, so the two portrait cases are listed before the wide fallback. */}
       <source
         media={'(min-width: 0px)'}
-        srcSet={`/images/vote-tally-${theme}-narrow.webp`}
+        srcSet={`/images/vote-tally-${theme}.png`}
         width={SHOTS.narrow.width}
         height={SHOTS.narrow.height}
       />
@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ function Shot({theme, alt, className}: {theme: 'light' | 'dark'; alt: string; cl
       {/*  height={SHOTS.narrow.height}*/}
       {/*/>*/}
       <img
-        src={`/images/vote-tally-${theme}-narrow.webp`}
+        src={`/images/vote-tally-${theme}.png`}
         alt={alt}
         width={SHOTS.wide.width}
         height={SHOTS.wide.height}
diff --git a/web/scripts/fetch-media.mjs b/web/scripts/fetch-media.mjs
index a75df924..3a54c451 100644
--- a/web/scripts/fetch-media.mjs
+++ b/web/scripts/fetch-media.mjs
@@ -47,8 +47,8 @@ const ASSETS = [
   {key: 'images/search-alert-poster-dark.jpg', dest: 'images/search-alert-poster-dark.jpg'},
   {key: 'images/vote-tally-light.webp', dest: 'images/vote-tally-light.webp'},
   {key: 'images/vote-tally-dark.webp', dest: 'images/vote-tally-dark.webp'},
-  {key: 'images/vote-tally-light-narrow.webp', dest: 'images/vote-tally-light-narrow.webp'},
-  {key: 'images/vote-tally-dark-narrow.webp', dest: 'images/vote-tally-dark-narrow.webp'},
+  // {key: 'images/vote-tally-light-narrow.webp', dest: 'images/vote-tally-light-narrow.webp'},
+  // {key: 'images/vote-tally-dark-narrow.webp', dest: 'images/vote-tally-dark-narrow.webp'},
 ]
 
 /**