mirror of
https://github.com/navidrome/navidrome.git
synced 2026-04-21 23:19:14 -04:00
664217f3f7
* fix: allow WAV direct play by aliasing pcm and wav codecs
WAV files were being transcoded to FLAC even when the browser declared
native WAV support. The backend normalizes ffprobe's pcm_s16le (and
similar PCM variants) to the internal codec name "pcm", while browsers
advertise WAV support as audioCodecs:["wav"] in their client profile.
The direct-play codec check compared these literally and rejected the
match with "audio codec not supported", forcing a needless FLAC
transcode.
Added {"pcm", "wav"} to codecAliasGroups so the matcher treats them
as equivalent. The container check runs first, so AIFF files (which also
normalize to codec "pcm" but use container "aiff") cannot
accidentally match a WAV direct-play profile.
* feat: include profile details in direct-play rejection reasons
The transcodeReason array returned by getTranscodeDecision previously
contained one generic string per failed DirectPlayProfile (e.g., five
copies of "container not supported"), making it hard to correlate a
reason with the profile that rejected the stream.
Each rejection reason now embeds the offending source value (in single
quotes) along with a compact representation of the full profile that
rejected it, rendered as [container/codec]. For example, clients with
two distinct ogg-container profiles (opus and vorbis) produced two
identical rejection strings; they now read "container 'wav' not
supported by profile [ogg/opus]" and "container 'wav' not supported
by profile [ogg/vorbis]", making each entry in the transcodeReason
array unique and self-describing.
A small describeProfile helper renders profiles as [container/codec]
(or [container] when no codec is constrained).
* refactor(stream): address code review — narrow pcm/wav match, tighten tests
Responds to reviewer feedback on the initial PR:
- Replace the symmetric pcm↔wav codec alias with a contextual
isPCMInWAVMatch check in checkDirectPlayProfile. The alias
unconditionally equated the two names in matchesCodec, which would
let AIFF sources (also normalized to codec "pcm") falsely satisfy
a codec-only ["wav"] direct-play profile that omitted containers.
The new check additionally requires src.Container == "wav" before
bridging the names, closing the false-positive path.
- Tighten the rejection-reason test assertions to verify the new
formatted output (source value + profile descriptor) instead of
just matching loose substrings like "container", preventing
unrelated rejections from satisfying the expectations.
- Add coverage for the WAV→wav-codec acceptance path and for the
AIFF-in-wav-codec-profile rejection path to pin down the contract
of isPCMInWAVMatch.
* refactor(codec): rename isPCMInWAVMatch to matchesPCMWAVBridge for clarity
Signed-off-by: Deluan <deluan@navidrome.org>
---------
Signed-off-by: Deluan <deluan@navidrome.org>