mirror of
https://github.com/danilo-znamerovszkij/c-atlas.git
synced 2025-12-23 22:17:53 -05:00
👨🏼🔧 fix DOPS & QRI
This commit is contained in:
Danilo Znamerovszkij
93
public/data/Dops.json
Normal file
93
public/data/Dops.json
Normal file
@@ -0,0 +1,93 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"id_and_class": {
|
||||
"theory_title": "DOPS Theoretical Framework",
|
||||
"summary": "This framework, supported by empirical research into phenomena like NDEs and reincarnation, advocates for a transmission or filter model of consciousness, where the brain acts as an interface rather than a producer of consciousness. It systematically challenges conventional physicalism by arguing that consciousness is independent of the organism and potentially foundational to reality.",
|
||||
"associated_thinkers": ["Ed Kelly", "Ian Stevenson", "Bruce Greyson"],
|
||||
"category": "Anomalous and Altered States",
|
||||
"subcategory": "Research-driven challenge to physicalism/materialism",
|
||||
"core_identity_tagline": "Consciousness as Filtered Universal Existence",
|
||||
"classification_tags": [
|
||||
"survival",
|
||||
"psi",
|
||||
"transmission model",
|
||||
"idealism",
|
||||
"non-physicalist"
|
||||
]
|
||||
},
|
||||
"conceptual_ground": {
|
||||
"explanatory_identity_claim": "Consciousness is identified as a more inclusive and capacious entity (the 'More') that exists independently of the organism, manifesting in everyday experience via a filter mechanism in the brain.",
|
||||
"ontological_status": "Objective or Realist Idealism (or Panentheism)",
|
||||
"mind_body_relationship": "Transmission/Filter model, where the brain serves as a sensorimotor interface that filters or reduces a more comprehensive, independent consciousness, opposing the physicalist 'production' model.",
|
||||
"primitive_or_emergent_status": "Primitive",
|
||||
"emergence_type": "Not applicable; consciousness is fundamentally primitive or universal (Idealist/Panentheistic basis) , with the brain acting as a filter/reducer.",
|
||||
"subjectivity_and_intentionality": "Derived from the interaction between the independent, comprehensive consciousness (the 'More') and the sensorimotor interface (the brain). Specific mechanism details are limited by source material.",
|
||||
"qualia_account": "Qualitative experience is inherent to the independent, comprehensive consciousness (Idealist foundation) and is transmitted or filtered by the brain. The irreducible nature of phenomenal consciousness is leveraged to attack physicalism.",
|
||||
"ontological_commitments": "Independent, nonphysical consciousness (the 'More'); psychophysical phenomena (psi, survival data) irreducible to physicalism; objective or realist idealism/panentheism as underlying metaphysics.",
|
||||
"epistemic_access": "Empirical study of non-standard psychophysical phenomena (NDEs, reincarnation cases) used to challenge physicalism and infer the nature of reality. Also draws on first-person mystical experiences.",
|
||||
"constituents_and_structure": "A structure involving a comprehensive, independent consciousness (the 'More') and the organism's nervous system acting as a transmission or filter mechanism."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"mechanism_and_dynamics": {
|
||||
"scope_of_consciousness": "Phenomenal (irreducible); Survival; Psi Phenomena; Mystical Experience; Prodigious Memory/Genius.",
|
||||
"distinctive_mechanism_or_principle": "The principle of transmission or filtering, where the brain limits the expression of a wider, non-physical consciousness.",
|
||||
"dynamics_of_emergence": "Consciousness is fundamentally existent (primitive). The manifestation of everyday consciousness is dynamically produced through the brain's interaction/filtering processes.",
|
||||
"location_and_distribution": "Fundamentally non-local, existing independently of the brain, consistent with Idealism/Panentheism foundations. Everyday consciousness is localized (dependent on brain interaction/filtering).",
|
||||
"causation_and_functional_role": "The brain's functional role is primarily to serve as a sensorimotor interface. The role of the deeper consciousness (the 'More') is to contain capacities and information, sometimes expressed as 'subliminal uprush'.",
|
||||
"integration_or_binding": "Likely achieved by the underlying unity of the independent, comprehensive consciousness (consistent with Idealist/Panentheist foundations).",
|
||||
"information_flow_or_representation": "Information and capacities normally confined to the 'More' are brought into everyday consciousness via 'subliminal uprush'.",
|
||||
"evolutionary_account": "Consistent with 'evolutionary panentheism,' suggesting consciousness or deep reality is prior or fundamental rather than a contingent, purely physical evolutionary product.",
|
||||
"core_claims_and_evidence": [
|
||||
"Demonstration of postmortem survival rules out most materialism theories.",
|
||||
"Experiences during extreme physiological conditions (e.g., NDE during cardiac arrest) challenge the physicalist production model.",
|
||||
"The model aligns with an objective or realist idealism/panentheism ontology."
|
||||
],
|
||||
"basis_of_belief_or_evidence_type": "Empirical (via structured research on anomalous phenomena, e.g., CORT, NDEs); Philosophical (Idealism/Panentheism); Phenomenological (mystical and non-standard experiences)."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"empirics_and_critiques": {
|
||||
"testability_status": "Empirically testable through ongoing investigation of anomalous phenomena (CORT, NDE verification) used to falsify physicalism; conceptually testable via metaphysical coherence.",
|
||||
"known_empirical_interventions_or_tests": [
|
||||
"Investigation of Cases of the Reincarnation Type (CORT) ",
|
||||
"Investigation of NDEs under extreme physiological conditions (cardiac arrest, deep anesthesia) "
|
||||
],
|
||||
"criticisms_and_tensions": "The empirical data underlying the theory (psi/survival phenomena) are generally not accepted by mainstream science and are often dismissed as illusion, delusion, or poor methodology.",
|
||||
"open_questions_and_limitations": "The precise form of the adequate theory (Idealism/Panentheism) must respect and incorporate modern physics discoveries. The mechanism of interaction between the 'More' and the brain requires further clarification.",
|
||||
"ontological_coherence": "Highly coherent with non-materialistic worldviews, particularly objective idealism/panentheism. Fundamentally designed to be ontologically incompatible with physicalism by presenting evidence of the mind's irreducibility."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"implications": {
|
||||
"AI_consciousness": {
|
||||
"stance": "Poor Prospects",
|
||||
"rationale": "The framework suggests consciousness is irreducible and tied to fundamental, universal reality (Idealism/Panentheism), thus implying that mere artificial/computational systems are unlikely to possess it, leading to poor prospects for AGI consciousness."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"survival_beyond_death": {
|
||||
"stance": "Likely",
|
||||
"rationale": "The theory is motivated by empirical evidence (NDEs, reincarnation cases) arguing that consciousness survives bodily death, thus requiring a non-material production model."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"meaning_and_purpose": {
|
||||
"stance": "Cosmic/Ultimate",
|
||||
"rationale": "The core metaphysical tendency toward Idealism/Panentheism suggests that consciousness is grounded in a highest consciousness which provides ultimate meaning, purpose, and value."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"virtual_immortality": {
|
||||
"stance": "No (Not Needed)",
|
||||
"rationale": "Since consciousness is non-physical and potentially continuous/surviving death, duplication (virtual immortality) would likely fail to capture the original first-person self or would be irrelevant if genuine survival occurs."
|
||||
}
|
||||
},
|
||||
"relations_and_sources": {
|
||||
"related_theories": [
|
||||
{
|
||||
"name": "Myers/James Transmission Model",
|
||||
"relationship": "Foundation"
|
||||
},
|
||||
{ "name": "Idealism/Panentheism", "relationship": "Compatible/Tendency" },
|
||||
{
|
||||
"name": "Interactive Dualism",
|
||||
"relationship": "Alternative Conceptual Framework"
|
||||
},
|
||||
{ "name": "Materialism Theories (General)", "relationship": "Critique" }
|
||||
],
|
||||
"sources_and_references": [
|
||||
{ "title_with_names": "Irreducible Mind", "year": 2007 },
|
||||
{ "title_with_names": "Beyond Physicalism", "year": 2015 },
|
||||
{ "title_with_names": "Consciousness Unbound", "year": 2021 },
|
||||
{ "title_with_names": "The Continuity of Consciousness", "year": 2022 }
|
||||
]
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
99
public/data/Qri.json
Normal file
99
public/data/Qri.json
Normal file
@@ -0,0 +1,99 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"id_and_class": {
|
||||
"theory_title": "QRI’s State-Space, Qualia Formalism, Valence Realism",
|
||||
"summary": "This model posits that consciousness is defined by its internal subjective structure ('Qualia Formalism'), which can be precisely represented mathematically as a vast 'state-space of consciousness' . Affective experience ('Valence Realism') is treated as a fundamental, real property within this space, quantitatively linked to the geometry's symmetry .",
|
||||
"associated_thinkers": [
|
||||
"Qualia Research Institute (QRI)",
|
||||
"Michael Edward Johnson"
|
||||
],
|
||||
"category": "Monisms",
|
||||
"subcategory": "State-Space, Qualia Formalism, Valence Realism",
|
||||
"core_identity_tagline": "Consciousness as Mathematically Representable State-Space and Valence",
|
||||
"classification_tags": [
|
||||
"qualia formalism",
|
||||
"valence realism",
|
||||
"state-space",
|
||||
"dual-aspect monism",
|
||||
"mathematical"
|
||||
]
|
||||
},
|
||||
"conceptual_ground": {
|
||||
"explanatory_identity_claim": "Consciousness is identified as an unimaginably vast, quasi-dimensional 'state-space of consciousness' . Phenomenal properties are fundamental features of the world, not spontaneous products of computation .",
|
||||
"ontological_status": "Dual-aspect monism or Neutral Monism . The framework is compatible with an extended physicalism where laws describe fields of qualia .",
|
||||
"mind_body_relationship": "Dual-Aspect/Neutral Monism. Consciousness (mind) is either a complementary aspect of physical reality (body) or derived from a common neutral substance .",
|
||||
"primitive_or_emergent_status": "Primitive (Phenomenal properties are fundamental features of the world ).",
|
||||
"emergence_type": "N/A (The core phenomenal properties are asserted to be fundamental, not emergent, distinguishing it from panprotopsychism variants ).",
|
||||
"subjectivity_and_intentionality": "Subjectivity arises intrinsically from the phenomenal structure of the fundamental qualia space . Intentionality (directedness of thought) is not explicitly detailed in the sources, but would be modeled mathematically within the state-space geometry.",
|
||||
"qualia_account": "Qualia (phenomenal properties) are formalized precisely by mathematical concepts, primarily geometry and symmetry (Qualia Formalism) . Valence (affective quality) is a real, fundamental, quantifiable property .",
|
||||
"ontological_commitments": "Phenomenal properties, a state-space of consciousness, and precise mathematical/geometric relations (Symmetry) .",
|
||||
"epistemic_access": "Accessible via rigorous mathematical modeling (Qualia Formalism) applied to the internal structure of subjective experience, complemented by phenomenological observation of valence .",
|
||||
"constituents_and_structure": "The basic structure is a vast, quasi-dimensional state-space defined by its geometry . Individual experiences are discrete geometric structures (points) characterized by their symmetries, which correlate with valence ."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"mechanism_and_dynamics": {
|
||||
"scope_of_consciousness": "Phenomenal (Qualia Formalism, Valence Realism) .",
|
||||
"distinctive_mechanism_or_principle": "The Symmetry Theory of Valence, stating that the pleasantness/unpleasantness of an experience is determined by the symmetry or lack thereof in the experience's information geometry .",
|
||||
"dynamics_of_emergence": "Dynamic Process (The state-space of consciousness is described as growing 'supergeometrically' and consisting of states constantly in motion, implying dynamic flow rather than a static substance ).",
|
||||
"location_and_distribution": "Systemic/State-Space. Consciousness exists in a vast, independent, quasi-dimensional state-space, compatible with fields of qualia (extended physicalism) .",
|
||||
"causation_and_functional_role": "Unspecified in terms of functional necessity. However, valence is treated as a real, defined property , implying a causal role in experience and potentially guiding adaptive behavior, though this mechanism is not provided.",
|
||||
"integration_or_binding": "Integration is inherent in the singular geometric structure that represents an individual conscious percept within the state-space .",
|
||||
"information_flow_or_representation": "Conscious processing is fundamentally informational and representational, fully reducible to mathematical patterns and structures (geometry) .",
|
||||
"evolutionary_account": "Not explicitly detailed. The model focuses on the fundamental structure of consciousness rather than its evolutionary origin, though phenomenal properties are not exclusively triggered by computation .",
|
||||
"core_claims_and_evidence": [
|
||||
"Phenomenal properties are fundamental features of the world .",
|
||||
"The internal structure of subjective experience (Qualia) can be precisely mapped by mathematics .",
|
||||
"Affective valence is a real property linked to the geometry's symmetry (Valence Realism/Symmetry Theory of Valence) ."
|
||||
],
|
||||
"basis_of_belief_or_evidence_type": "Conceptual; Phenomenological; Mathematical (Formalism) ."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"empirics_and_critiques": {
|
||||
"testability_status": "Conceptual/Mathematical (Requires correlating mathematical models of phenomenal structure/valence with measured experiences) .",
|
||||
"known_empirical_interventions_or_tests": "None explicitly listed in the source, but research likely involves correlating highly specific emotional or perceptual states with predicted symmetries in underlying neural activity/information structure.",
|
||||
"criticisms_and_tensions": "The theory rejects functionalism , distinguishing itself by requiring mathematical formality rooted in phenomenology. Must overcome the challenge inherent in monisms: linking the abstract phenomenal structure (state-space) to physical reality.",
|
||||
"open_questions_and_limitations": "The precise nature of the quasi-dimensional state-space remains unspecified, as does the exact mechanism by which mathematical symmetry translates to qualitative valence .",
|
||||
"ontological_coherence": "High, as it is self-consistent and explicitly attempts to formalize phenomenal experience, adhering to a dual-aspect monist or neutral monist stance ."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"implications": {
|
||||
"AI_consciousness": {
|
||||
"stance": "Uncertain/Conditional",
|
||||
"rationale": "Consciousness requires replicating precise mathematical and geometric structures within the state-space, a condition difficult to verify or implement in non-biological substrates; moreover, the theory explicitly rejects simple computational functionalism ."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"survival_beyond_death": {
|
||||
"stance": "Possible",
|
||||
"rationale": "As a monist theory classifying phenomenal properties as fundamental and non-reducible to specific biological matter , the existence of consciousness is not contingent on the survival of the biological brain/body, allowing for post-mortem persistence of the phenomenal state-space in some form."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"meaning_and_purpose": {
|
||||
"stance": "Conditional/Intrinsic",
|
||||
"rationale": "Valence ('goodness' or 'badness') is considered a fundamental, intrinsic property of conscious states , implying an objective basis for value, though cosmic teleology is not explicitly claimed."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"virtual_immortality": {
|
||||
"stance": "Conditional",
|
||||
"rationale": "Possible only if technology can fully capture and perfectly replicate an individual's unique geometric conscious structure within the vast state-space, which demands extreme precision beyond current understanding ."
|
||||
}
|
||||
},
|
||||
"relations_and_sources": {
|
||||
"related_theories": [
|
||||
{
|
||||
"name": "Integrated Information Theory (IIT)",
|
||||
"relationship": "Compatible/Overlap (Shares and leverages the concept of mapping conscious experience to unique mathematical structures) ."
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"name": "Panpsychism",
|
||||
"relationship": "Compatible (QRI states its view 'mostly fits well with a panpsychist view') ."
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"name": "Functionalism",
|
||||
"relationship": "Critique (QRI explicitly rejects functionalism) ."
|
||||
}
|
||||
],
|
||||
"sources_and_references": [
|
||||
{
|
||||
"title_with_names": "Qualia Formalism and a Symmetry Theory of Valence",
|
||||
"year": 2023
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"title_with_names": "QRI FAQ",
|
||||
"year": null
|
||||
}
|
||||
]
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user